pingfatigue.com is an independent, vendor-neutral reference on alert fatigue. Not affiliated with PagerDuty, Atlassian, Splunk, or any other vendor. Tool comparisons may contain affiliate links, clearly labelled.
Home/On-Call Cost
COST CALCULATOR

The True Cost of Being On-Call: Engineer Hours, Burnout, and Retention in 2026

Updated April 2026 | Sources: incident.io 2024 State of On-Call, SHRM replacement-cost formula, Gloria Mark 2023, Levels.fyi

An engineer handling 42 pages per week at $180K fully-loaded costs $61,000/year in alert-handling time alone, before burnout, replacement, or incident amplification.

on-call-cost-calculator.exe
Team size (on-call)6
Your on-call rotation size
Pages per engineer per week42
incident.io 2024 median = 42
Base salary ($K/yr)$180K
Levels.fyi SRE median ~$180K
Attrition probability (%)41%
incident.io 2024: 41% have considered leaving
Night pages per month (per engineer)8
62% report weekly sleep disruption (incident.io 2024)
Direct cost (per engineer / yr)
$147,645
Alert-handling + night premium
Direct cost (whole team / yr)
$885,870
Across all on-call engineers
Expected attrition cost / yr
$664,200
Probability x replacement cost
Total annual burden
$1,550,070
Direct + expected attrition

The Four Cost Components

01
Direct alert-handling time

Minutes per page multiplied by pages per week multiplied by hourly rate. Includes: reading the alert, opening the runbook (or searching without one), investigating, attempting resolution, documenting the outcome. At MTTA + 23 minutes per page and 42 pages per week, this is 24.5 hours per week of engineering time per on-call engineer. That is more than half a working week consumed by alerts.

02
Context-switching penalty

Gloria Mark (UC Irvine, 2023) found that after an interruption, engineers require an average of 23 minutes to return to full cognitive engagement with the prior task. A 5-minute alert investigation actually costs 28 minutes of productive time. For engineers doing complex distributed-systems work (incident investigation, capacity planning, architecture), this penalty is severe.

03
After-hours premium

Night and weekend pages carry a cost premium beyond the direct time. Sleep disruption degrades next-day cognitive performance (Stanford research: one night of disrupted sleep reduces complex problem-solving ability by 30-40%). The 62% weekly sleep disruption rate from incident.io 2024 means most on-call engineers are operating below cognitive capacity on a chronic basis.

04
Retention and replacement cost

The SHRM replacement-cost formula puts senior technical talent replacement at 1x-1.5x annual salary, covering: recruiter fees (20-30% of base), interviewing time (40-80 engineering hours), offer overhead, signing bonus, new hire ramp (6-9 months to full productivity). At a $200K senior SRE base, replacement cost is $200K-$300K. With 41% attrition intent in the population, every team of 10 engineers has roughly 4 in the at-risk cohort.

Burnout Signals Table

Signals that indicate on-call load has crossed into burnout territory. Data from incident.io 2024 State of On-Call Survey (n=500+).

SignalPrevalenceThreshold to act
Weekly sleep disruption from pages62%Any frequency above monthly
Considered leaving due to on-call load41%Track quarterly; >20% = urgent
Acknowledging alerts without investigationNot surveyed>10% of ack'd alerts closed without action
Skipping post-mortemsNot surveyedAny skip on a P1/P2 incident
Declining to participate in game daysNot surveyedTwo consecutive skips
Requesting rotation removalNot surveyedImmediate: single request is a data point
Performance degradation in code reviewNot surveyedNoticeable quality drop after on-call weeks
Sick days spiking after on-call weeksNot surveyedCorrelation over 3+ months
Late alert acknowledgement (MTTA rising)Industry: 8-15min medianMTTA > 20min on stable systems
Expressed resentment in retros / 1:1sQualitativeAny: this is a direct signal

ROI of Fixing It: A Worked Example

SCENARIO: team of 8 SREs, 6-month alert hygiene programme
Investment (tooling + audit + training)
$40,000
Hours returned (1.5 FTE x $180K)
$270,000/yr
Expected retention improvement
$96,000/yr
2 fewer at-risk engineers x $48K expected attrition saving
MTTR improvement savings
$80,000/yr
Fewer missed P1s x reduced incident duration x $500/min cost
NET ROI (12 months)
$406,000
$446K returns minus $40K investment. Payback: <2 months.

FAQ

How much does on-call cost per engineer per year?+
At the industry median of 42 pages per week, a fully-loaded $180K/year engineer spends roughly $61,000/year on direct alert-handling time alone (MTTA + 23-minute refocus per page). Add after-hours premium and the figure exceeds $80,000. This excludes the 41% attrition-intent probability, which carries a $200K-$300K replacement cost if actualised.
What is the cost of replacing an SRE who quits because of on-call load?+
Using the SHRM replacement-cost formula (1-1.5x annual salary for senior technical roles), a senior SRE at $200K base costs $200K-$300K to replace including recruitment, interviewing, onboarding ramp, and lost productivity during the gap. The incident.io 2024 survey found 41% of on-call engineers have considered leaving specifically because of alert volume.
How do you calculate the ROI of reducing alert fatigue?+
ROI = (Hours returned to engineering * fully-loaded hourly rate) + (Retention improvement * expected replacement cost savings) + (MTTR improvement * reduced incident cost per outage). A team of 8 SREs reducing pages from 42/week to 14/week recovers approximately 1.5 FTE in direct time, worth $270K/year at a $180K fully-loaded cost, before any retention or MTTR benefit.
What is the Gloria Mark 23-minute rule?+
UC Irvine researcher Gloria Mark's research (2004, updated 2023) found that after an interruption, it takes an average of 23 minutes and 15 seconds to fully return to a complex cognitive task. For on-call engineers, each page carries this 23-minute context-switching penalty in addition to the time spent investigating the alert itself. Her 2023 work notes the figure has compressed slightly for digital workers who have adapted attention strategies.
Alert Fatigue CalculatorMTTR ImpactAlert TuningRunbooks & On-CallTools Comparisonoutagecost.com